Living through a moral panic

Written by

in

we want to make it clear that we do not tolerate comments like hers in this dorm. Our theme… is intended to make this space safe and fun for you this quarter.”

The supposed transphobia isn't enough: she's now anti-semitic and racist as well. And no doubt disablist, homophobic, and ageist too. Probably not so great with the personal hygiene either, come to mention it. And see those warts? Yep, she's a witch.

Right now, we are living through a moral panic. This panic goes by many names (wokeness, cancel culture, identity politics, etc) and it is corroding major institutions, including journalism, government, and academia. When otherwise thoughtful and well-intentioned people — in this case liberals concerned about racism, broadly speaking — get caught up in the panic, evidence and process become secondary considerations, and narratives take over.

Rowling’s witty heroine Hermione Granger once observed that "Fear of a name only increases fear of the thing itself." Our moral panic has produced an environment where the fear of a word like “racism” has disproportionately increased fear of the thing itself. Let me explain:

The goal of increasing societal awareness of racism where it exists is both laudable and desirable. But we are no longer in a stage of increased awareness — or even hyper-awareness — of racism. We are now witnessing the mass hallucination of racism. The obsessive search to uncover bigotry in everything and everyone has led people to see bigotry where none exists.

Comments

  1. Shir Avatar
    Shir

    Just no.
    It’s like people need to live under real racist despots in order to appreciate freedom. Otherwise they just celebrate anything anti-democratic with a religious vigor.

  2. AlanS Avatar
    AlanS

    I’d be prepared to bet that these self-declared Goodthinkers would not be able to cite one single actual antisemitic statement that J.K. Rowling has made in the last year, or for that matter in the last 20 years. She has, on the contrary, gone out of her way to pillory antisemitism when she perceives it, especially but not exclusively among those who have the chutzpah to call themselves ‘progressive’; just google ‘rowling antisemitic’ for the evidence. The allegations against her seem to be a matter of guilt by remote association. I speak as one who has never read a word of any of Rowling’s books, and has no desire to do so.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *