A homegrown problem with roots that are specific to the left

Written by

in

r their own purposes.’ It is thus here – at the intersection of antisemitic antizionism and traditional Judeophobia, where leftists are overrepresented – that the true source of the Labour antisemitism crisis is to be found. It is not an import from the right, or a random statistical quirk, but rather a homegrown problem with roots that are specific to the left. […]

 The alternative to condemning British Jews to the status of fools at best, or liars and propagandists at worst, is for the left to acknowledge that the way it has long understood antisemitism, Israel, and the idea of Jewish nationhood is not only historically and conceptually flawed but is itself tainted with antisemitism. But this would mean challenging not just axiomatic beliefs about Israel but an entire worldview, one built on conspiracy, irrationality and projection. Corbyn’s statement and ongoing refusal to withdraw it is thus as much a defence of this ideological edifice as it is an evasion of his responsibility for the crisis.

But read it all.

Comments

  1. Joanne Avatar

    exactly philo-semitic, then at least anti-antisemitic. And this orientation was strengthened with the rise of fascism.
    Many people with only a superficial knowledge of history will think that the left is by definition tolerant of Jews, but antisemitism has deep roots on the left, again coming to the fore under Stalin in the late 1940s/early 1950s, in the USSR thereafter, in Czechoslovakia in the early 1950s (e.g., the Slansky trial), and in Poland in the late 1960s.
    So, apart from the anti-Zionism of the Soviets and the New Left, antisemitism on the left could draw on the traditional left-wing themes of Jewish conspiracies, control of the banks, their being the force behind world capitalism, etc. These themes only seem new because they were suppressed for several decades after World War Two.

  2. Michael van der Riet Avatar
    Michael van der Riet

    I don’t exactly have pro-semitic credentials. Where I grew up I was the only yok on the block and the only one of my friends who did not have a bar mitzvah. But I do have more than an intellectual understanding.
    I think that the Jewish religion has a lot of house cleaning to do before it becomes respectable, no not respectable in the Cambridge sense but acceptable by polite society. The prejudice against marriage with gentiles is the most objectionable, together with various mitzvoth that diminish the status of women. Kosher doesn’t belong in the modern world. Forced circumcision is a very dubious practice.
    I’m a strong atheist. I actively disbelieve in the existence of gods. Yet I believe that those who believe in something have an advantage over those who believe in nothing at all. I’m hoping that in time a New Islam will arise, free of its barbaric roots and free of the superstitious revelations that plague Judeo-Christianity.

  3. Joanne Avatar

    d the other not; it just depends on which method is being used. But, like many Jews, I don’t know too much about it.
    You’re hoping that a new Islam will arise. Fair enough, but new forms of Judaism have been arising since the 18th century, as a result of the Enlightenment and greater Jewish participation in European civilization. That’s why you have “Conservative” Judaism, which is actually way more liberal than the traditional orthodox; and Reform Judaism, which came out of Germany in the early 19th century; and Reconstructionist Judaism, which started in the US in the late 20th century, I believe, and is extremely liberal.
    Funny, but people generally don’t realize that the Hasidic movement, which I find a bit dubious, is also relatively new, having started in the mid-18th century, around the same time as the founding of the Amish and Mennonites.
    As for circumcision, it isn’t forced. And, at least in the States, it’s a common practice generally, done at hospitals by non-Jews as well, because it was long considered better for men’s health. Jews would have a ceremony to mark it, but the practice was done for just about everyone.
    So, the Jews have been doing “housecleaning” for 200 years.

  4. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Well said Joanne.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *