’s about the principles of open debate and free speech, which to the national library should be sacrosanct.
“It isn’t too late to redeem the situation. But if there is not a change of heart, I feel I will have no choice but to publicly dissociate myself from the exhibition and the campaign that surrounds it.
“This stupid escapade does not undo the very good work the library does, but it should never have happened.
“I couldn’t say definitely that I will not donate any more money if they stick to their guns on this, but it has certainly given me pause for thought. That makes me incredibly sad.”
It's always the same story – management running scared and caving in to the demands of their trans-fixed young staff.
“This book [The Women Who Wouldn’t Wheesht] was clearly selected to be included, and frankly the management were then bullied out of that by a staff lobby group.
“They say they’ve removed this book to protect relationships with stakeholders. But they certainly didn’t consult me and if they had, I would have voiced strong opposition. I am angry and disappointed at the decision to remove the book as well as the implication that as a stakeholder, I am somehow supportive of it, which I am not.”
Added: Jo Bartosch.
Once upon a time, the views of public servants such as librarians were both unknown and considered irrelevant. Professionalism meant separating the personal from the job. Now, thanks to social media’s culture of exhibitionism, the distinction between public and private has collapsed. Middle-class jobs in the cultural sector – which generally come with modest pay but high status – have become magnets for zealots whose main professional output seems to be policing the ideological hygiene of bookshelves and flaunting their lanyards.
The result is an arms race of censorship, in which public servants signal to their peers that they possess the approved views. What the public thinks – the great unwashed who actually fund these institutions – barely registers. If the staff at the National Library did not like the choices the Scottish people made, perhaps they should not have asked them in the first place.
Stop calling it ‘curation’. Call it what it is: censorship in the service of the cultural elite.