Early humans and the extinction of the megafauna

how much they respected the glories of nature.

In fact if anything it's surely the other way round. No doubt it's something of an over-simplification to say that before the Romantics people used to shun mountains and wild nature as ugly and frightening, but there's surely some truth in it. Only we moderns go off in search of the world's most desolate places, and only we moderns spend vast amounts of time and effort setting up national parks, trying to preserve endangered species, making films about the beauty of our world – and then build up decadent romantic fantasies about how nasty modern life is, and how our noble ancestors used to live in harmony with nature.

Baz Edmeades has a book, Megafauna, First Victims of the Human-Caused Extinction, out next year.

Comments

  1. Shir Avatar
    Shir

    Very interesting thanks.

  2. TDK Avatar
    TDK

    It’s the modern take on the “noble savage” myth.

  3. Recruiting Animal Avatar
    Recruiting Animal

    Years ago I saw a TV show about a tribe in South America. They lived in the jungle and moved their village every so often. And when they did they used slash and burn tactics to carve out a new home.
    Many cowboy movies make a point of nothing that the white man killed far more buffalo than the Indians. The claim is made that it was because of a cultural lack of sensitivity. But, based on what I’ve read here, maybe it was because they had a big market for the skins whereas the Indians didn’t.

  4. Mick H Avatar
    Mick H

    Well yes. But of course the slaughter of the bison herds for their skins was a savage and stupidly short-sighted business. John Williams’ Butcher’s Crossing is a great read on the subject – https://www.amazon.co.uk/Butchers-Crossing-Vintage-Classics-Williams/dp/0099589672/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=butcher%27s+crossing&qid=1599670952&sr=8-1

  5. djf Avatar
    djf

    “Such depictions of the benign and gentle ways of Indigenous peoples are perhaps well-intentioned, an antidote to the racist depictions of so-called ‘savages’ that have been common currency in the West for generations.”
    The “racist depictions of so-called ‘savages’” have not been “current” in the West for at least the last three generations. It is astonishing how otherwise insightful people still carry on about the West’s “racism” as if nothing had changed in the West since World War I.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *